Success (2003–07)
Zinta was the female lead in India's three highest-grossing films of 2003: The Hero:
Love Story of a Spy, Koi... Mil Gaya and Kal Ho Naa Ho. The Hero, co-starring Sunny Deol
and Priyanka Chopra, is a patriotic drama about a spy network involving terrorists and
an Indian army officer. Zinta played the part of Reshma, a villager who falls in love
with the officer and becomes part of this network. The film, involving stunts never seen
before in the cinematic history of Bollywood, became the most expensive Hindi film ever
produced at the time. Despite being the third highest-grossing film of that year, it
failed to recover its production costs at the box office. She next starred in Honey
Irani's directorial debut, Armaan, alongside Amitabh Bachchan and Anil Kapoor. This
drama is set in a hospital and follows the travails of its personnel and its principal,
Dr. Akash, who struggles arduously to sustain the institution financially. Zinta played
Akash's schizophrenic wife Sonia Kapoor. The film received predominantly positive
reviews, and Zinta was particularly praised. The Tribune concluded, "Zinta has
outclassed everyone with her convincing performance." For her performance, she received
nominations for Best Villain at different award ceremonies, including Filmfare.
Rakesh Roshan's science-fiction film Koi... Mil Gaya, about a developmentally disabled
young man, followed. Co-starring with Rekha and Hrithik Roshan, Zinta played the role of
Nisha, a young woman whom Roshan befriends. She received another Best Actress nomination
at the Filmfare for the role. The movie was a financial and critical success and became
the most popular film of the year, as well as Zinta's highest-grossing movie, with a
domestic total of Rs 425 million; it won the Filmfare Award for Best Movie, among
others.
Zinta's final release of 2003 was Kal Ho Naa Ho, a tearjerker set in New York City. It
was directed by Nikhil Advani and written by Karan Johar, co-starring Jaya Bachchan,
Shahrukh Khan and Saif Ali Khan. The film was received favourably by critics and became
India's second-biggest hit of the year after Koi... Mil Gaya. It also did well
internationally and became India's top-grossing film of the year overseas, earning over
Rs 750 million worldwide. Zinta played the role of Naina Catherine Kapur, an insecure
and angry young Indian-American woman who falls in love with a man who has a fatal heart
disease. She won several awards for her performance, including the Filmfare Award for
Best Actress. Derek Elley from Variety wrote, "Zinta, who's been carving a growing
following the past three years or so, has never been better, definitively moving from
juve roles to a charismatic young woman with her sexy, assured Naina."
In 2004 she starred as TV journalist Romila Dutta in Farhan Akhtar's war drama Lakshya,
co-starring with Hrithik Roshan. The film was based on the historical events of the 1999
Kargil Conflict; Zinta's character was modeled after TV journalist Barkha Dutt, the only
female reporter assigned to the story. The film was a critical success, yet her
performance received mixed reviews; Rediff.com noted, "Zinta has quite a good role and a
good deal of footage in the film, and she does a fairly decent job of it without ever
being spectacular." Later that year, Yash Chopra cast her opposite Shahrukh Khan as the
female lead in the love saga Veer-Zaara, the top-grossing Hindi film of that year in
both India and abroad, with revenues of over Rs 900 million worldwide. The film, which
relates the love story of an Indian officer, Veer Pratap Singh, and a Pakistani woman,
Zaara Haayat Khan, had a strong international release, including a screening at the
Berlin Film Festival, and won several Best Movie awards at major Indian award functions.
For her portrayal of Zaara, a smart Pakistani girl, Zinta received her fourth Filmfare
Best Actress nomination. Variety hailed her as "the most interesting young actress of
her generation," writing that she "is her usual lively self as the willful Zaara." Veer
-Zaara was Zinta's second highest-grossing film and third major success in two
consecutive years. It marked the beginning of her work with Yash Raj Films, one of the
largest production houses in Bollywood.
In 2005, Zinta appeared in two movies. Her first release was the folk comedy Khullam
Khulla Pyaar Karen, co-starring Govinda, a production that had been delayed since 2002.
The film garnered negative reviews and poor box office returns. Zinta's role was small,
and was not well received. Her next release was Siddharth Anand's comedy-drama Salaam
Namaste, co-starring Saif Ali Khan. Produced by Yash Raj Films, it was the first Indian
feature to be filmed entirely in Australia and went on to become the year's highest-
grossing Bollywood production outside of India, earning Rs 570 million internationally.
The film tells the story of a contemporary cohabiting Indian couple and their subsequent
struggle with an unexpected pregnancy. Zinta played the female protagonist Ambar
Malhotra, a single modern young woman who leaves India to make her own life in
Australia. The film was well received by critics, and Zinta's performance earned her
nominations for Best Actress at a number of award ceremonies. Taran Adarsh wrote, "After
Kya Kehna, Preity Zinta accepts the challenge of portraying an unwed mother yet again in
Salaam Namaste. The actor is terrific, delivering her most accomplished performance to
date." The New York Times noted, "She is cheerleader-homecoming queen-fraternity
sweetheart pretty, so even when her characters are being unkind it's hard not to like
her."
Zinta received further success in 2006, starring in Karan Johar's drama Kabhi Alvida Naa
Kehna with an ensemble cast including Amitabh Bachchan, Shahrukh Khan, Abhishek
Bachchan, Rani Mukerji and Kirron Kher. The film became one of the biggest box office
hits in India, earning Rs 458 million, and grossed over Rs 480 million abroad, the
biggest Bollywood success of all-time in the overseas market up until then. It was her
fourth overseas top-earner in four consecutive years. The film tells the story of two
unhappily married couples in New York, and an ensuing extramarital affair. Zinta played
the role of Rhea Saran, an ambitious fashion magazine editor. She described the role as
an attempt to shed her vivacious public image. The Indian Express concurred that this
was successful: "The lady has not just looked glamorous but she has walked with poise,
sat with grace, smiled with composure and spoke with calmness. Who would have thought
that the bubbly girl could so skillfully shed her age-old tag and walk away as the
don't-mess-with-me lass. So all those who are in search of the peppy Preity, well guys
you've dialed the wrong number this time."
She then starred in Shirish Kunder's romantic musical Jaan-E-Mann, a story set in the
United States about two men, played by Salman Khan and Akshay Kumar, who love the same
woman. The film opened to mixed reviews from critics and its eventual box-office profit
was poor. Zinta played the role of Piya, the cynosure of two men. She was mostly
criticised for taking a role of minimal importance, though her performance was generally
well-received. Raja Sen labelled her role an "ornament throughout," but further stated
that she "comes vividly alive in the film's last scene, a moment that makes you lament
why filmmakers today don't let the babyfaced actress have more fun instead of forcing
her to sob copiously. She doesn't have much to do in Jaan-E-Mann, but looks
appropriately attractive." Zinta said that the film was a great relief after the more
emotionally intense Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna, as Jaan-E-Mann was "easy, happy and much
more simple".
In 2007 Zinta portrayed a British Pakistani woman, Alvira Khan, in her third project
with Yash Raj Films, Shaad Ali's comedy Jhoom Barabar Jhoom, alongside Abhishek
Bachchan, Bobby Deol and Lara Dutta. The film was a critical and commercial failure in
India. She was criticised for her performance; The Times of India described her as "too
plastic" and Rediff.com concluded, "From accent to emotion, Preity is plain and simple
insufferable in this film."